On paper, it seemed perfect: a versatile low-gain overdrive with a boost that sits perfectly atop my 5W Laney L5 Studio tube amp for practice. I mostly play cleans-EOB and wanted something to give the amp a clean-channel push, provide some pick emphasis and open-up some dirt when digging-in. I am not comparing it to the pedal it is supposedly based on.
Each to their own, but for my taste it not so transparent and is somewhat lacking in dynamics. There is always a trebly 'hair' that I cannot dial-out, even when using EQ before it and in the amp FX loop. I find that the tone knob has a very limited range, it only properly kicks-in at the highest settings - above 90% and seems to act in an exponential way. Across most of its range the sound is generally darker than the clean signal, even muddy, dulling note definition. I would definitely not call it 'creamy', it is somewhat harsh and slightly metallic in nature; it doesn't sweeten the tone. To me, it sounds somewhat better through a dirty amp channel, or even when put through another overdrive that can round-off the edges. But that kind of defeats the purpose of why I wanted this pedal in the first place.
The Hard Clipping setting sounds least 'hairy' but then it doesn't feel like an overdrive, more of a clean boost.
Although I knew beforehand that the boost cannot be used alone, it was still a disappointment. Boosting the OD only accentuates the qualities I mention above.
I'm not trying to come across all negative. I can see how it can suit some setups along with other pedals. At the price it's still probably worth a punt if you are considering it, but I wouldn't rely on it as my only overdrive. I think Joyo make some really good pedals, but this one didn't do it for me.